Table of contents
Table of contents
We’re igniting
a movement.
Together, we can mobilize a generation of givers that’s driven by purpose, powered by technology, and ready to usher in a new era of impact.
Scott Brighton
CEO, Bonterra
Change can seem overwhelming, especially in times of crisis. But it also creates momentum, reminding us that nothing stands still — and neither should we.
At Bonterra, we’re asking: Why has charitable giving and volunteering in the US remained stuck at 2.5% of GDP for over 50 years? It’s not a lack of generosity. Americans want to give. But barriers — like eroded trust, limited transparency, and unstable federal funding — get in the way. We believe technology can remove those barriers.
We’re building the Generosity Generation: a multi-age community of donors, volunteers, funders, and nonprofit leaders. With the right tools, this community can diversify support, respond to crises faster, build lasting relationships, and empower corporations to fairly contribute.
At Bonterra, we aim to increase giving to 3% of US GDP by 2033 — our 3% by ’33 initiative — and the Generosity Generation can help achieve this mission.
This year, we reimagined our impact report. We’re celebrating the progress of our customers and sharing information on the AI-powered Bonterra Network, and we’re also surfacing insights that nonprofit leaders, companies, and individuals can use to activate the Generosity Generation.
Because together we can create a more generous world.
Table of contents
Nonprofits
Convert prospects
into champions
Challenge
Nonprofit donor retention
Nonprofits spend a huge amount of time and money seeking donors. Not only that: Donor retention rates are declining for nonprofits in the US, with only 19.4% of new donors being retained.
Action
Be timely and persistent
Bonterra processes 443K donations daily, and the data shows that the key to donor retention is to focus on converting first time donors to second-time donors. Sustained giving can be unlocked by doubling down on this pivotal moment in a donor’s lifecycle.
Invest in email
Each email link click generates an average of $39 in donations.
Pick your moment
Nonprofits see higher engagement when emails are sent mid-morning on Tuesdays and Thursdays; avoid weekends and late evenings to improve open rates; 25-30% is a benchmark open rate for nonprofits to aim for or above.
Ask upfront for recurring donations
While on average 7% of supporters will opt-in at the first ask, this pool accounts for 78% of an organization's total recurring donors on average — making it a crucial opportunity for conversion that you can attain from the start.
Don’t wait to ask again
First-time donors are more likely to give again if you re-engage within the first two months. Just make sure you highlight the impact of their first gift and thank them before asking for continued support.
Persistence pays off
Donors who give second gifts are nearly 5x times more likely to become sustained donors.
In your Bonterra toolkit
EveryAction and Network for Good
Optimized Ask, a tool within Bonterra’s fundraising and engagement solutions, employs AI-powered, targeted donation requests to realize a 11% increase in dollars raised per form load.
Learn moreDonorDrive
A peer-to-peer fundraising platform that gives donors the option to increase their donation to offset processing and technology costs: 78% of donors elect to cover processing fees when enabled by default, resulting in a 2.41% revenue lift for customers.
Learn moreCustomer spotlight
Making organic
movements
How the National Wildlife Refuge Association mobilized grassroots support
“It's really important to diversify your funding stream. The ecosystem of foundations is changing a lot, but the grassroots networks are more important now than ever, and I think we have more technology to tap into those networks than we did before.”
Eden Taylor
Director of Communications and Marketing,
National Wildlife Refuge Association
Organization
Challenge
Solution
Call to action
Organization
Founded in 1975, the National Wildlife Refuge Association (NWRA) provides essential habitats for endangered species, supports biodiversity, and offers communities natural flood and storm protection, as well as clean water.
Challenge
Changes in current political power are having an immediate impact on the NWRA and its 570 refuges across America.
“The refuge system has already been subject to budget cuts for the last 15 years, and now these mass firings,” says Eden Taylor, director of communications and marketing at NWRA. “We're going to be seeing things like no access for hunting and fishing, no endangered species monitoring, no one to manage volunteers.”
In response to federal funding uncertainty and turbulence, NWRA is doubling down on diversification efforts, using smart tools to build a base of individual private funders and grassroots supporters.
“Our main goal right now is to build up that grassroots network of supporters that care about the national wildlife refuges,” says Eden. “We used to have some federal funding, but over time, we’ve wanted to wean ourselves off that. We've been trying to build out our foundation arm and rely more heavily on sustaining donors, as well as individual donors.”
Solution
To build their diverse base of supporters, NWRA has stepped up its digital infrastructure. Individual donors require ease and intuitive interfaces to more easily commit to long-term support. The system it used previously only offered basic email and clunky forms that didn’t offer a positive user experience.
The NWRA team embraced a new fundraising dashboard — Bonterra EveryAction — that makes it simpler for team members to manage their workload and engage the next generation of lifelong supporters.
Most importantly, the user experience makes it easy and fun for supporters to get involved. “One of our main goals is to build the next generation of conservationists — reaching out to kids and getting them involved with nature," says Eden. The platform helps engage friends of the program at every age, letting them know about opportunities that range from storytelling to beach cleanup.
Call to action
Leveraging tools and social media, NWRA is building a movement across local networks, educating the public on what’s at stake and harnessing the power of community voices to make change. “We're seeing a lot of the advocacy that we used to do as nonprofits isn't quite working anymore; we need to get more savvy with social media and with media in general, because congressional members just aren't paying attention unless it’s an uprising that shows their voters care about these things,” says Eden.
Foundations + Nonprofits
Find your ideal
funding match
Challenge
Time demand of finding funding
Finding a suitable match for funding sucks up a lot of time for the team: 41% of NPOs lack the necessary readiness to manage every phase of the grant process, while insecurity around federal grants puts more pressure on nonprofits to diversify funding.
Action
Diversify and don’t give up
Bonterra data shows that the winning strategy to receive the most dollars is to use smart tools that allow you to make more applications, and keep going until you get results — an approach that can also improve fundraising diversification. Now streamlined digital dashboards and AI-powered grant platforms offer an efficient way to put a “more is more” approach into action swiftly.
Make multiple applications
Nonprofits that apply for more grants receive more funds on average, even if they also receive several rejections.
Don’t give up after rejection
63% of nonprofits give up after one rejection. But on average, it takes 1.24 applications to receive funding.
Go back to the well
Overall, 52% of nonprofits that reapply to the same funder, or apply to a different funder, receive funding. 49.13% are approved by the same funder if they reapply.
Try more, smaller requests
Nonprofits that apply to multiple smaller grants end up receiving more funds on average than nonprofits that apply to one larger grant.
In your Bonterra toolkit
CyberGrants
A unified platform for employee engagement and grantmaking that supports the most innovative CSR teams, including 50 of the Fortune 100.
Learn moreJumpstart
A cohort-based, capacity-building program that enables funders to empower their nonprofit partners — on average, funders experience a 10x philanthropic ROI and participants quadruple their donations from individual giving.
Learn moreCustomer spotlight
Capacity
unlocks action
How Michigan Health Endowment Fund created capacity where it was needed most
“If we don't have well equipped nonprofits, we don’t have partners to create impact with.”
Veronica Marchese
Program Officer,
Community Health and Capacity Building
Organization
Challenge
Solution
Call to action
Organization
The Michigan Health Endowment Fund (the Health Fund) works to improve Michigan residents’ health and wellness, with a special focus on children and seniors, while reducing the cost of healthcare.
Challenge
The Health Fund was created to expand access to quality healthcare in communities across Michigan, with a particular focus on children and seniors. While the organizations it serves vary, they all face a shared challenge: a lack of capacity.
“We know that all of our organizations — rural, urban — are all very different, but all often constrained by the same thing, which is tighter budgets, restricted funding,” says Veronica Marchese, program officer, community health and capacity building at the Health Fund. “So we thought about how else we can equip them outside of grantmaking.”
In 2020, when COVID-19 was spreading globally, the Health Fund needed to offer its grantees active support to make sure they were able to keep operating as needs and technology solutions evolved rapidly. Now that need for support is growing, as federal funding is more uncertain and nonprofits are scrambling to diversify their funding streams and find new funders.
“We saw a lot of requests for fundraising, fund development, adding development staff, and they weren’t requests we could keep up with,” says Veronica. “I think every organization that we serve and those that we don't serve could benefit from some fundraising support and a fundraising strategy. It's such a large need for our partners, so we were looking at other opportunities on how we could support fundraising outside of our grantmaking dollars.”
Solution
The Health Fund invested in Bonterra Jumpstart, which offers their grantees a combination of coaching and technology, empowering them with the skills and tools they need for long-term viability and success. Offering expert thought partnership has been especially transformational for the smaller nonprofits that the Health Fund supports, where leaders are required to turn their hand to a lot of different tasks.
Veronica recalls one particular beneficiary: Alpena Cedar Senior Citizen Center. “They started with just a few thousand dollars for their year-end campaign, and after going through Jumpstart, they ended up with $30,000 — and they had only amazing things to say about how exciting it was to see that huge growth.”
Another Health Fund grantee, MiGen, focuses on supporting the elder LGBTQ+ community in Michigan. Right now, MiGen is feeling the instability of the current political turbulence and is grateful to be better equipped to respond to the moment through support from the Jumpstart program.
“Participating in Jumpstart meant we had the space to take a risk and see if the technology worked out for us without the outlay of additional cash resources,” says Executive Director Angel Gabridge, who started with the organization three and a half years ago, from the grassroots up. “It also meant being able to access discounted pricing moving forward and access to a coach who was instrumental in helping us unlock the full potential of the platform. The rich engagement data we are able to pull from the platform is outstanding, and reporting is so nimble and does not require a middleman. Our engagement metrics, event ticket sales, sponsorships, and individual donations have all more than doubled as a direct result of participating in Jumpstart.”
Call to action
Veronica is happy to see this support in action. She is also clear-eyed about the need for more — more tools and more coaching support to keep progress moving in pace with her community’s needs and the changes across the country.
“It's critical that we're committed to working with the nonprofit sector that we have in our state, and that we're investing in its strength and its resources to keep doing the work that they're doing,” says Veronica. “If we don't have well-equipped, well-resourced nonprofits around the state, we don’t have partners to create impact with.”
Corporations + Nonprofits
Respond to crises
in real time
Challenge
Nonprofits under pressure
The majority of Americans who donate give to charities supporting disaster relief. Bonterra data shows that during 2020–23, relief organizations often saw a substantial increase in giving soon after natural disasters and significant cultural moments.
Action
Plan ahead and be bold
When a crisis occurs, 52% of Americans say they do not know where to find reputable information on how to direct a monetary donation to support those in need. Nonprofits must be prepared for scaled-up communications, fast-paced pivots, increased donations, and the opportunity to expand their long-term supporter base.
Start fundraising early
In the case where a crisis or significant cultural moment is predicted (e.g., a hurricane hitting a coast or a judgment from the Supreme Court being delivered), nonprofits that start fundraising ahead of time often experience a surge in donations up to 1 day before and 3 days after.
Based on data in response to 2022-23 hurricanes, nonprofits experience an average 1,308% surge in funding the week before and up to three days after the storm — so it pays to ask for larger amounts immediately, and more regularly.
Prepare for new donors
Nonprofits see an average 1,735% increase in new donors at the peak of a natural disaster due to a dramatic lowering of trust barriers and increased need. In the two weeks after the murder of George Floyd in 2020, Black Lives Matter (BLM) organizations attracted over 400,000 new donors.
Be ready to focus locally
Based on data analysis of the Dobbs ruling in 2022, local organizations experienced an average 2,105% increase in total donations around the leak date and an average 5,170% increase around the Supreme Court decision.
Expect big surges for social crises
Similarly, BLM nonprofits saw a 7,190% surge in the total amount of donations when major social justice milestones occurred in 2020, compared to regular days.
In your Bonterra toolkit
CyberGrants
FrontDoor, a solution within CyberGrants, features a connective platform where nonprofits and corporations can meet, with 160,000 rigorously vetted organizations looking for sponsors.
Learn moreEveryAction
Reach your audience with confidence using EveryAction's email marketing, backed by exceptional sending infrastructure with a 99% delivery rate.
Learn moreNetwork for Good
With best practices and coaching built into an all-in-one fundraising solution, Network for Good delivers measurable results and a 480% ROI.
Learn moreCustomer spotlight
Nimbleness
requires readiness
How Texas Diaper Bank used digital tools to manage a hurricane of help
“You need to have the right software in place to be able to handle a flood of donations.”
Jorge Medina
CEO and Founder, Texas Diaper Bank
Organization
Challenge
Solution
Call to action
Organization
Founded in 2013, Texas Diaper Bank is a nonprofit dedicated to providing diapers, incontinence supplies, and essential resources to families, seniors, and individuals in crisis across Texas.
Challenge
Jorge Medina, CEO and founder of Texas Diaper Bank, recalls the day when his organization entered rapid expansion mode. It was August 25, 2017, the day Hurricane Harvey made landfall as a Category 4 hurricane, setting off catastrophic flooding throughout Texas. Within days, Jorge's small nonprofit operation providing diapers and personal care supplies became the center of national attention.
“When a disaster happens and people are being evacuated, the last thing that they're going to pack are these types of essentials,” says Jorge. “They arrive at a shelter and they are welcomed with a warm bed and some food, but none of these essentials are being provided.”
This was the first time the organization had addressed a disaster as large and widespread as Harvey. The team quickly sent out a press release outlining the imminent needs of their community. NPR picked up the story that night, and by the next morning, everything changed.
“We started getting phone calls from different places — foundations, celebrities — wanting to donate,” says Jorge. “It was almost like a hurricane in itself, a good hurricane, where we were inundated with people wanting to help with either money, product donations, or their time.”
Solution
Thankfully, Jorge had recently decided to integrate Bonterra Network for Good, in part to be able to accept online donations and manage donors.
“Bonterra Network for Good software was so important for us because it allowed us to have a way of managing this multitude of donors,” he says. It also made it possible to process monetary donations fast, which was integral to hiring staff and procuring warehouse space to address the influx of product donations. “We couldn’t have done that if we couldn’t tap into the actual dollars being donated.”
Texas Diaper Bank, which had previously worked from a 6,500-square-foot facility, now occupies 30,000 square feet, offering diapers plus incontinence and menstrual products. And, it has recently teamed up with DoorDash to offer delivery services. With its increased capacity, the team is better able to respond to other pressing events, like social crises and demographic shifts, in addition to natural disasters. For example, it serves the growing “silver tsunami” of senior Texans needing care and the influx of refugees into American cities as conflicts and climate impacts ramp up worldwide.
Call to action
When asked to sum up the value of using digital fundraising software, Jorge comes back to the moment when Hurricane Harvey hit.
"Having this type of software is imperative. This is something that you need to have, because when something like this does happen, you need to have the right software in place to be able to handle this flood of donations that's going to come."
Nonprofits
Invest in the
power of trust
Challenge
Figuring out the formula for trust
After four years of decline, trust in nonprofits has rebounded by 5 points, but it remains at 57%. No one knows the precise formula for trust, but Bonterra’s data suggests it starts with key building blocks: listening to needs, being transparent, and following through on what you said you would do.
Action
Get closer and customize
Nonprofits can solidify their supporter relationships by proactively customizing them. Plus, real-time data analysis puts outcomes at our fingertips — valuable proof that shows communities how they are keeping their word, and gives funders instant confidence in their theory of change.
Trust is valuable
Sustained donors are a tangible measure of trust as they continue to believe in and support your organization. Plus, over the course of approximately 10 years, they give an average of 8x as many donations and 2.5x the amount compared to non-sustainers.
Customize your ask
Targeted requests based on personalized donation history helps increase dollars per donation by 11%.
Empower trust holders
Peer-to-peer software allows supporters to build their own network of support for your mission, activating 3x more fundraisers while reducing staff time by 6x.
Know your program’s benchmarks
Trust plays a significant role in health, human, and social services organizations serving participants in need. Understand your program’s average completion rate and weigh it against the sector average:
In your Bonterra toolkit
DonorDrive
The DonorDrive Charity Fundraising App puts powerful peer-to-peer fundraising tools in supporters’ hands, increasing the average raised per fundraiser by 154%.
Learn moreApricot
Case management software designed for caseworkers to streamline operations, automate reporting, and win funding — helping deliver an average of 3.5x more services due to efficiencies gained.
Learn moreComing soon
Bonterra Network will leverage AWS cloud-powered dashboards that track real-time impact and make reporting to your stakeholders and funders easier and faster.
Customer spotlight
Being data-driven
is a mission imperative
How Wilmington Alliance leveraged technology to build trust in Delaware
“If we’re going to be result-driven, we have to be data-driven. And to be data-driven, we have to have the knowledge and discipline and tools.”
Renata Kowalczyk
CEO of Wilmington Alliance
Organization
Challenge
Solution
Call to action
Organization
Founded in 2019, Wilmington Alliance partners with community, civic, and business leaders to drive economic opportunity and social vitality, as well as launch initiatives for equitable wealth creation in underserved populations.
Challenge
Renata Kowalczyk, CEO of Wilmington Alliance, is a champion of data integration. Leading a busy, locally focused organization in constant fundraising mode, she prioritizes real-time data-sharing with stakeholders — from funders to community members. The organization’s impact dashboard gives her team instant access to what they need, and it frees the team to focus on their program.
“In the past, when we needed to provide updates to the board or founders [all of whom like information in specific formats], we would have to do it manually from spreadsheets,” says Renata. The organization’s dashboard, powered by Bonterra Apricot, changed that. “We have a very easy way to communicate, not only to our founders but, frankly, to anyone who asks us a question.”
Solution
Being able to track outcomes and speak to the organization’s progress against goals is essential for reporting, and it also builds trust. With decades of experience working in the corporate world, Renata understands what founders and potential investors need to see and know in order to offer their support, as well as the biases people bring when they work with the social sector for the first time. Having data at Renata’s fingertips has been transformative in building confidence with new funders — it opens doors that previously would have been closed.
"Business leaders in the community have told me, 'I’m hearing that you run this shop with an incredible level of data and acumen and transparency. I can’t wait to sit down with you and explore what more we can be doing together,'" says Renata.
“It empowers me as the CEO to be much more effective in my role as a champion and advocate and chief salesperson,” she adds.
Call to action
Some might think that data integration is not necessary for every nonprofit. Renata disagrees. Having experienced the transformation that the data dashboard has made for her and her team, she underscores the importance of this type of digital empowerment for the survival of the sector at large.
“We collectively need to get much better, quickly, at sharing and amplifying the work,” says Renata, “because we are only going to be asked to do more.”
Foundations + Corporations
Strengthen
giving at work
Challenge
Low employee engagement
According to recent polls, employee engagement is at a 10-year low. If workplace giving is not prioritized, employers lose talent and nonprofits will miss out on vast amounts of individual donations and volunteer time, including matched giving which contributes an estimated $2-3 billion a year.
Action
Share stories and get competitive
Bonterra data shows that CSR teams should bring digital trends from outside the workplace into the office — making donations frictionless with digital platforms, catching employees’ attention with bite-size content and other social storytelling, and harness people’s inherent love of competition by gamifying their impact experience.
Gamify giving
Matched giving rates increase by 22% and payroll giving rates by 20% when companies use leaderboards to track giving activity across the company and motivate employees through gamification, inspiring them to hit higher targets.
Digitize to drive donations
Companies that empower employee giving using digital wallets see nearly 50% higher engagement rates and an almost 90% increase in donation amounts.
Increase your donor count
Social feeds alone increase donor count by 50%, and digital wallets add another 14% on average.
Match your employees
Corporations that offer employee donation match see 1x more donations per donor and 3x higher average amount per gift than those that don’t.
In your Bonterra toolkit
CyberGrants
In 2024, CyberGrants customers collectively delivered more than $8B in grants, 8 million volunteer hours, and $1 billion in employee giving to nonprofits.
Learn moreDonorDrive
Passing the megaphone to peer-to-peer supporters, DonorDrive helps share meaningful connections to nonprofits causes. Fundraisers who personalize their stories increase the amount they raise by 376% on average.
Learn moreMobilize
A volunteer management platform that taps into a shared network of mission-driven organizations to drive up to 45% more signups — without added outreach effort.
Learn moreCustomer spotlight
Harnessing a culture
of giving for greater good
How Ally Financial uses tools to exceed employee engagement expectations
“The power of Insights is a slam dunk. Being able to demonstrate a positive community presence and outcomes for nonprofits — that’s what people want to see.”
Lynne Walters
Senior Director of Corporate Citizenship,
Ally Financial
Organization
Challenge
Solution
Call to action
Organization
Ally Financial is a 100-plus-year-old financial institution and is home to America’s largest all-digital bank.
Challenge
Ally, a financial services company founded over 100 years ago, has a “Do It Right” spirit that runs through the entire business. As an exclusively online operation, the team at Ally is technology forward, and Ally Charitable Foundation was an early adopter of Bonterra CyberGrants.
As part of Ally’s broader Corporate Citizenship team, Lynne leads a team of five that provides operational excellence, data analytics and governance, and brings volunteer and giving programs to life. One of the group’s key roles is to bridge the gap between business and impact, and leverage technology to scale its efforts. Bonterra CyberGrants allows the team to make a compelling case to key decision-makers internally. “If I can’t demonstrate the ROI, executives at the top have a difficult time understanding the nuance of why giving back is important,” says Lynne. “This tool — particularly the implementation of Insights — has been a game-changer.”
Solution
Having insights on hand enables Ally team to show how it outperforms competitors, which creates ongoing momentum for impact work and shines a light on Ally’s secret sauce: company culture. Starting from the top with its CEO, Ally demonstrated a unique level of commitment to the communities it serves. And now it has the data to prove it.
“Our employee giving last year showed 73% of our employees engaged in some way in the community. Looking at comparative organizations in the financial industries, the benchmark is 32% — so we are a clear head-and-shoulders above,” says Lynne. “The power of Insights is a slam-dunk tool. Being able to demonstrate a positive community presence and outcomes for nonprofits — that’s what people want to see.”
Ally is on an upward trajectory when it comes to making a bigger impact, and Lynne is grateful for the efficiency and creativity that tools like CyberGrants has brought to her team. “The tool allows us to meet employees where they are, no matter where they are,” she says. Employees at Ally love the easy interface of CyberGrants, which makes it able to “fish” for causes to support; and Lynne and her team save time by using automated communication templates to keep staff up to date on opportunities for impact. This gives them more space to innovate and deepen engagement.
Call to action
Ally has 128 team members across the business who lead the charge on impact projects locally. Lynne’s team can’t be everywhere at once, so Bonterra’s tools are crucial to empower other driven team members across the country, helping them to organize events, track outcomes, and see who signed up. “It’s a one-stop shop,” says Lynne.
Using smart technology and tools to drive impact has been a win-win for Ally. “Corporations get better at making funding decisions and telling stories,” says Lynne, “and nonprofits have more access to funds that are available. Rather than two ships passing in the night, we are meeting them right where they are.”
Nonprofits
Evaluate your
fundraising strategy now
Want to understand how your fundraising performance stacks up?
Use the following interactive tool to evaluate your strategy, uncover where you stand in the sector, and get clear next steps to boost retention and results.
Your evaluation is
The Drop-offs
You've mastered the art of securing substantial gifts, which is crucial to successful fundraising. However, your below-average retention rate signals that donors aren't staying connected to your mission after making their initial contributions. Let's turn your attention to building lasting donor relationships.
Enter your information to receive custom strategies to help improve donor retention.
Your evaluation is
The Champions
Congratulations, you're a Champion! Your organization has both a high average gift size and strong donor retention, which means you've mastered two of the most challenging aspects of fundraising: securing substantial gifts and maintaining donor loyalty.
Enter your information to receive custom fundraising strategies that will continue to grow your impact.
Your evaluation is
The Rebuilders
With both donor retention and average gift size below sector benchmarks, your organization faces significant fundraising challenges. Yes, there's work to do, but this position offers a valuable opportunity create a solid foundation for sustainable growth.
Enter your information for custom donor retention and fundraising strategies.
Your evaluation is
The Potentials
Your organization has achieved a loyal donor base. But despite your supporters returning, their individual gift amounts fall below sector averages. You have all the elements needed for significant fundraising growth by leveraging existing donor loyalty to increase average gift size.
Enter your information for custom strategies to up your donor contribution amounts.